The Green Series - Article 3 Part 3
Photo by Brandon Lee on Unsplash
To address the challenges posed by climate change, green practices have emerged as a major solution. The primary barriers to green hospital adoption in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) are categorized into financial constraints, systemic and policy deficits, infrastructural limitations, and a lack of specialized staff knowledge, particularly in healthcare systems across LMICs (such as Türkiye, Pakistan, and Indonesia)
Barriers To Green Hospital Adoption
There are several barriers which hinder the implementation of green practices, spanning individual, institutional, geographical, political, and other levels. While institutional barriers encompass costs, conflicting protocols, inadequate staffing, and leadership deficits. Geographical barriers relate to municipal infrastructure and public awareness, and political barriers involve a lack of incentives. Healthcare policymakers and administrators can enhance the adoption of green practices and improve sustainability in healthcare facilities while mitigating the effects of climate change. Following are the major barriers:
Knowledge and Cultural Barriers: The employees’ resistance to change, lack of top management support, institutional barriers, and educational barriers fall under this heading. Barriers such as lack of education, time constraints, and bureaucratic complexity hinder the adoption of sustainable practices in healthcare. Addressing these barriers is crucial for successful green practice adoption. The barriers are as under:
(1) There is a pronounced absence of specific educational programs and general awareness regarding the long-term cost savings and health benefits of green practices.
(2) Resistance to changing routine operational procedures by clinical and administrative staff often blocks the adoption of eco-friendly protocols. Financial and Economic Barriers:
The adoption of green practices can be resource-intensive, posing a challenge for adoption. Furthermore, economic factors such as discounted power purchases and higher costs can deter hospitals from implementing sustainable practices. While, the significant capital required for infrastructural changes also presents a financial barrier. However, these challenges can be overcome with careful planning and management. These barriers include:
(1) The upfront capital investment for green infrastructure, smart energy management, and renewable energy (e.g., solar panels) is to frequently unfeasible for hospitals operating on limited public or private budgets.
(2) Because many Low- and Middle-Income Countries (LMICs) face a high burden of infectious and non-communicable diseases, limited financial resources are almost exclusively directed giving prioritization to direct patient care that is toward life-saving clinical interventions rather than sustainability initiatives
Environmental:
This heading includes challenges in developing countries and infrastructural barriers. In developing nations, the integration of green practices in healthcare centres is hindered by inadequate support and resources. The financial burden of incorporating environmental sustainability infrastructure is a significant barrier. While, the use of toxic chemicals in hospitals and waste from operating rooms and haemodialysis activities are key considerations for environmental sustainability. Therefore, reducing harmful chemicals and waste can enhance the environmental friendliness of these centres.
Policy and Lack Of Leadership Barrier:
This refers to issues such as government policies and regulations, political support, promoting autonomy, and prioritizing preventative care. Renewable energy adoption is significantly influenced by varying policies and regulations across countries, which determine the available incentives and support. These barriers include:
(1) Unlike in high-income regions, LMICs often lack of standardized frameworks, tailored national policies, guidelines, and clear protocols for green healthcare facility construction and operation.
(2) Administrative insufficient managerial support and focus on cost cutting combined with a lack of long-term sustainable business models hinders adoption, leading managers to stick to conventional, less expensive methods. e. Limited Structural and Infrastructural Support: Technological advancements can enhance the viability and effectiveness of renewable energy solutions, thus promoting their use. These barriers include:
(1) Retrofitting older existing hospitals to meet green standards is often structurally and economically impossible.
(2) The localized unavailability of eco-friendly medical products and sustainable building materials severely restricts implementation.
(3) Ineffective segregation and disposal facilities act as major hurdles to sustainable healthcare waste management (HCWM).
Operational:
This heading refers to issues such as healthcare bureaucracy, patient refusals, workload, lack of time, chemical use, waste production from operating rooms and haemodialysis activities, and concerns about patientcare and infection control as operational barriers. The adoption of green practices may raise concerns about potential impacts on patient care and infection control, posing substantial obstacles to hospital sustainability.
References
1. Khosravi M, Mojtabaeian SM, Sarvestani MA. A systematic review on the outcomes of climate change in the Middle Eastern countries: the catastrophes of Yemen 2024;18:11786302241302270. and Syria. Environ Health Insights.
2. Vallée A. Green hospitals face to climate change: between sobriety and resilience. Heliyon. 2024;10(2):e24769.
3. responding Khosravi M, Zare Z, Marzaleh MA, Izadi R, Shojaei P. Towards to climate change: healthcare centers. Discov Sustain. 2024;5(1):375.
4. practices in Iranian Mahmood H, Meraj G, Hassan MS, Furqan M. Bioenergy expansion and economic sustainability from environment tenergy-food security nexus: a review. Int J Sustain Dev Plan. 2024;19(8):2813-2823